
Wine Paring 101
For some reason, the holiday season always opens the door for all sorts of debate about food and wine pairings. Just put in a quick Google search for “Thanksgiving wine pairing” and you’ll see what I mean. When I read a lot of these articles I can’t help but think of that scene in City Slickers where Ira and Barry (shameless caricatures of Ben and Jerry) challenge Billy Crystal’s character to stump them with an ice cream pairing (YouTube Video).
Truth is, Billy Crystal was right on the money in showing how subjective and arbitrary a lot of pairings seem. With wine, people just assume that they need an expert to share sacred nuggets of wine dogma handed down from the damp and hallowed Brettanomyces-ridden cellars of ancient French chateaux in order to get the “correct” pairing for their meal. In reality the whole deal is both a lot simpler and a lot more subjective than that.
There are two keys to wine pairing. First and most important is balance. You want a wine that won’t overpower your food. The same way you wouldn’t want to smother your delicate sea bass fillet (sustainably raised of course) with even the most delicious chipotle mole prepared by Rick Bayless himself, you probably wouldn’t want to pair that fillet with a big-giant-knock-your-socks-off Cabernet. At the same time, you don’t want the food and wine overpower one another. A pepper-crusted ribeye might make a light and fragrant Pinot Gris taste unexpectedly watery, or a sweet wine that would be great with chocolate cake might make your maple glazed sweet potatoes seem less sweet. The key is to pick a wine that compliments your food. In a good pairing, both the food and the wine can showcase their fine points without being overwhelmed by the other.
The strategy that I like use when coming up with a pairing is what I call match or contrast. It’s kind of like when getting dressed, I can either match a navy jacket with a navy tie, or go in the complete opposite direction and contrast it with a bright yellow one. When a food offers a certain flavor, a wine pairing can aim to match the food, like serving an earthy red Burgundy to go with with the earthiness of a mushroom risotto or a really fruity young red to compliment the fruit of duck with a berry reduction. However, you can also go in the other direction and pick a wine that will provide contrast for the flavors of the food, like choosing a Gewurztraminer that has touch of sweetness to balance the spice of Thai or Indian food, or using the acidity of Riesling or Barbera to cut the fattiness of greasy or fatty food.
The most important thing to remember is that there are no right and wrong answers, as long as the food and wine don’t overpower each other and the flavors work well together. So when pairing a wine with your Thanksgiving or Chanuka meals, keep these things in mind. Generally for Turkey and cranberries I like to go for lighter fruity reds like Pinot Noir, Grenache, or Barbera or fragrant whites like Gewurztraminer or a well made Muscat, but hey, you know the rules, if you don’t like those, go make your own pairing!
