Cheese, tomato sauce, dough. Pizza, with its three basic ingredients, is really a very simple food*. Why then is good pizza so hard to find? While that may be a good question – possibly even a great or profound one – it is not a question I am going to answer here. Instead let’s focus on something a bit more practical. Given that there is so much bad pizza out there, where can you go to score a good slice?
It is in search of the answer to this question that I sought a guru in India went to Rosa’s Pizzeria, located on the ground floor of the Empire State Building. I’d been hearing great things about Rosa’s for a while, but I just never made my way over there. I can’t say exactly why I didn’t go until now, but I can tell you that I feel like an idiot.
There is no outside entrance to Rosa’s, so you are forced to find your way through the labyrinthine hallways of the massive building’s lobby. Navigation is not my strong suit (I’m a food critic not a cartographer) but I managed to find the restaurant with little difficulty. Now that we’ve gotten directional issues out of the way, let’s talk about pizza!
I tried the plain pizza, a “Grandma” slice (cut in a square with thin crust, loads of sauce, topped with mozzarella and parmesan), a fried eggplant slice, a roasted pepper slice, a broccoli and mushroom slice, a “Margherita” slice (like the “Grandma” but more traditionally shaped), and a tomato and mozzarella slice. Upon hearing my excitement about trying his restaurant for the first time, the owner brought me a batch of fresh-out-of-the-oven dough knots (think garlic knots, sans garlic), which were delicious.
All of the slices were excellent, but there were really two highlights for me, the “Grandma” slice and the roasted pepper slice. The mozzarella and parmesan featured on the “Grandma” complemented each other perfectly and the pepper slice was not only topped with delightfully crisp slices of pepper, it looked beautiful to boot. The sauce on both (which is the sauce they use on all slices) had a unique and satisfying sweetness that managed not to be overpowering despite its robust flavor.
I’ve heard people say that Rosa’s is expensive at $2.75 for a regular slice and $4.00 for a topping slice (though the slices are big and everything is steeply discounted if you buy a pie). Relative to other pizza places this may be expensive, but based solely on the quality of the food, it’s the best kind of bargain. If you’re looking for a good slice of pizza, you really can’t do much better than Rosa’s Pizzeria.
*note: Pizza seems like a simple food, but it really isn’t. There are so many questions: What kind and how much cheese should you use? What flavor should the sauce have? Should that flavor dominate the pizza or should the cheese take center stage? Should the dough be thin or thick? Should it be crispy or soft? But this isn’t pizza-making 101, it is pizza-eating 9000 and it is a robot from the future.
Rosa’s Pizza
350 Fifth Avenue
New York, NY 10001
(212) 244-7672