When I walk into Supersol located at 661 Amsterdam Ave., I walk into my happy place. Yes, the aisles are narrow and the place is usually crowded, but the food is always worth it. I don’t love to cook, so when I prepare a meal, convenience is key. Plus, I don’t like to daven over my menu when I’m food shopping; so, what’s so nice about Supersol, is that my favorite dishes are always in stock and I can get in and get out fairly quickly. But that’s not even the pretzel on the chicken (opposed to the icing on the cake) – the best part about Supersol, is that you can order online and they deliver!
Now to help you with your Shabbat Prep, I’m going to share the menu I always put together when I’m hosting. Over the years, I’ve tried a number of Supersol’s meats, kugel, challahs, desserts – you name it. And I’ve found this list always makes the biggest hit with my guests.
My musts …
Starters:
Vegetables and Hummus – you can’t go wrong. Pick up the baby carrots in a bag, some bell peppers, crackers or chips — Stacy’s Pita chips are the BEST! — and put them out with some hummus and drinks before your guests arrive. If it’s a Friday night, your guests may have skipped lunch and be hungry from a long day and from being in shul. So I think it’s nice to always have a little something out while you wait for all of your guests to arrive. Plus, it’s not fair if you’re waiting for your last guest to come for your prompt guests to have to sit there hungry and thirsty. Even if you just have pretzels and some sodas out, that’s a good start.
Deli Roll – this is HEAVEN on Earth. I’m not kidding. I just had this for the first time recently and I don’t know how I’ve made it this far in life without it. Really, it was one of the best dishes I’ve tried in my LIFE. Don’t walk – run to Supersol to try this now. It’s a bit of a heavier dish, so if you have big eaters, starting with this will help fill them up.
The Meal:
Challah – I go back and forth between Zomick’s and Zadies. But stay tuned for an upcoming post on the best Challahs in NYC! (If you have any suggestions, please let me know!)
Gefilte Fish – you can buy this from the freezer or from the deli. I go with the deli because I know I won’t cook it myself. I love Supersol’s gefilte fish because it’s not fishy and even my friends who hate gefilte fish will eat it from Supersol.
Tuv Taam Horseradish – if you like horseradish, but don’t like the old bitter kind, try this stuff! It’s awesome! It’s sweet and has a kick.
Pretzel Chicken – This is also on my list of Top 10 Favorite Foods of All Time. I have gotten every family member and friend HOOKED on this chicken. Even my non-Jewish friends ask to come over to my place for Shabbat because they’ve become addicted, too.
Meatballs – I love Supersol’s meatballs, but I don’t always get them because they’re expensive. If you’re not worried about your budget, then don’t go home without them!
Homemade Sweet Kugel or Spinach Noodle Souflee – The sweet kugel is always amazing and tastes incredible with the pretzel chicken because you get the whole salt and sweet thing taken care of. The Spinach Noodle is very good too, but I recommend that if you’re serving Supersol’s plain grilled chicken, instead.
Homemade Cran-apple Crunch Kugel – Everyone always loves this kugel because it’s great on its own; but, it’s also so sweet it can be served for dessert. It’s more like a cobbler than it is a kugel. Delish!
Dessert:
Sharon’s Sorbet – These are always a hit because there’s a flavor for everyone.
Chocolate or Cinnamon Babka – I always associate Babka with Shabbat. Yum!
This is my go-list when I know I want to have people over, but don’t have time to cook. I never buy my fruits and vegetables at Supersol because they are SOOOOO overpriced it’s absurd. Some of their prepared dishes, soups, side salads seem a little expensive for my taste, but that’s just the nature of kosher food shopping. I wish Supersol had a club card and that members who spend x amount get a $10 coupon or something like that. You can get a discount if you buy the MJE Express Card (for more info, check out jewishexperience.org). But even so, the place is amazing. It has a loyal following, but it’s not so crazy when you go shopping like it is in Fairway (I fear for my life in that place!). But it would be nice if Supersol did more for the customer. They offer coupons if you order online for the first time, but I really think they should consider doing some sort of rewards program.
So there you have it! Let me know what your musts are when you shop at Supersol and what you think is a bust!
Happy Noshing,
KK
Click here for the Supersol UWS listing