Mike's Pizzeria and Italian Kitchen

Italian, Pizza, Salad, Soup, Pasta

654 Amsterdam Avenue
Upper West Side
Manhattan, New York City, 10025

Telephone:
(212) 362-0700

Sunday: 11:30 am - 10:00 pm
Monday: 11:30 am - 10:00 pm
Tuesday: 11:30 am - 10:00 pm
Wednesday: 11:30 am - 10:00 pm
Thursday: 11:30 am - 10:00 pm
Friday: 11:30 am - 3:00 pm
Saturday: 9:00 pm - 1:00 am

Is our information accurate?

D/M/P

Supervision

Food

Value

Service

Atmosphere

Overall

Write your own review

Share/Save/Bookmark

(closest 10 results)

Supersol - Supermarket, Butcher, Take Out, Fish
661 Amsterdam Avenue , Upper West Side, 10025
0.026 miles away

Talia's Steakhouse & Bar - American, Middle Eastern, Steakhouse
668 Amsterdam Avenue , Upper West Side, 10025
0.038 miles away

Rita's Ices - Dessert, Ice Cream, Yogurt
2486 Broadway , Upper West Side, 10025
0.066 miles away

Dunkin Donuts - Bagels, Coffee, Breakfast, Sandwich, Donuts
687 Amsterdam Avenue , Upper West Side, 10025
0.078 miles away

Gan Asia - Thai, Chinese, Sushi, Oriental
691 Amsterdam Avenue , Upper West Side, 10025
0.087 miles away

Bagel Basket - Bagel, Sandwich, Pizza
618 Amsterdam Avenue , Upper West Side, 10024
0.097 miles away

Peaches - Ice Cream, Yogurt, Dessert
2543 Broadway , Upper West Side, 10025
0.106 miles away

The Kosher Marketplace - Supermarket, Butcher, Take Out, Fish
2442 Broadway , Upper West Side, 10024
0.108 miles away

Caffe Mocias - Cafe, Breakfast, Coffee, Sandwich, Dessert
711 Amsterdam Ave. , Upper West Side, 10025
0.144 miles away

Cafe Viva - Cafe, Italian, Pizza, Salad, Sandwich
2578 Broadway , Upper West Side, 10025
0.203 miles away

What Koshertopia has to say:


Food 5

Value 4

Service 4

Atmosphere 3

Overall 4

What kreviewer has to say:

Posted on 08/30/2010

I highly recommend Mike's Pizzaria for its delicious individual pizza creations and the gourmet paninis. The ingredients are what set the food apart--fresh basil, hearty Parmesan, and home-made pesto. The downsides of Mike's Pizzaria have to do with the small sitting area--I almost always wait for a seat and often feel pressured to rush through the meal so that others can have a seat. As a final note, the menu has recently been changed so that the salads are "choose your own". In other words, you choose the elements of your salad from a list. While the check-list offers some exciting options--including candied walnuts and sun-dried tomatoes--be careful. Sometimes I have ordered things off the checklist and they don't seem to make it to the salad bowl.

Food 5

Value 3

Service 3

Atmosphere 4

Overall 4

What introducingyael has to say:

Posted on 08/24/2010

Great food, but small portions.

Food 5

Value 4

Service 5

Atmosphere 4

Overall 5

What elipongo has to say:

Posted on 04/06/2010

Very friendly staff, the pizza is crispy & fresh. Nice clean and bright and pleasant dining area. They also have wide area, yet prompt delivery.

There are no menus at this time.

Kosher La-Mehadrin (Rabbi Avrohom Marmorstein)

276 Riverside Drive, Suite 1D
New York NY, 10025
Phone: (212) 866-3442
Website: www.mehadrin.org

View our full list of Kosher Supervisors...